Timber Vs Composite Decking Adelaide

Decision Guide

Timber vs Composite Decking in Adelaide

Which material actually suits your backyard?

Composite decking now outsells timber in most Adelaide postcodes because homeowners are sick of oiling merbau every summer. But composite has its own trade-offs — heat retention in direct sun, a huge quality gap between $180 and $520 per m² ranges, and a very different aesthetic. This guide is the honest comparison on cost, longevity, heat and maintenance for Adelaide conditions.

Timber Decking (Merbau / Spotted Gum / Blackbutt)

Pros

  • Cheaper upfront — merbau installed from $310/m²
  • Cooler underfoot in direct sun (15-20°C cooler than composite)
  • Natural material — ages with character
  • Can be sanded and refinished if damaged
  • Australian hardwoods (spotted gum, blackbutt) are highly durable
  • Works better in shaded / south-facing decks

Cons

  • Annual re-oiling required in Adelaide UV
  • Grey-weathers within 12 months without maintenance
  • Fixings visible unless secret-fixed (adds cost)
  • Some warping and cupping expected over time
  • Merbau leaches red tannins onto light-coloured paving
  • Termite risk if not H3-treated

Best For

  • • Shaded or south-facing decks
  • • Homeowners willing to oil annually
  • • Traditional / character home aesthetics
  • • Budget projects using merbau
  • • Buyers wanting a genuine timber feel underfoot

Composite Decking (Modwood / Ekodeck / Trex)

Pros

  • Zero annual maintenance
  • 20-25 year manufacturer warranties on quality brands
  • Doesn't splinter, warp or leach tannins
  • Consistent colour and grain
  • Won't rot in Adelaide's wet-winter/dry-summer cycle
  • Higher resale appeal — buyers see 'maintenance-free'

Cons

  • Higher upfront cost — $380-$520/m² installed
  • Gets hot underfoot in direct sun (60-70°C on 38°C days)
  • Cheap Chinese composite fades and cracks within 3-5 years
  • Can't be refinished if scratched — must replace boards
  • Feels less 'natural' underfoot than timber
  • Some brands fade or chalk in Adelaide UV

Best For

  • • Full-sun decks where pale composite avoids heat issues
  • • Homeowners who won't do annual maintenance
  • • Rental properties and holiday homes
  • • Long-term resale focus
  • • Around pools where salt / chlorine damages timber

Cost Comparison per m² Installed (Adelaide Feb 2026)

Category
Timber
Composite
Note
Budget tier
Merbau $310-$360/m²
Cheap composite $260-$340/m²
Skip cheap composite — 3-5 year lifespan in Adelaide UV
Mid tier
Merbau premium install $360-$420/m²
Modwood $380-$470/m²
Modwood is the most popular mid-tier composite in Adelaide
Premium tier
Spotted gum / blackbutt $450-$620/m²
Trex Transcend / Ekodeck $460-$520/m²
Australian hardwoods at this tier outperform composite on heat
20-year total cost (including maintenance)
Merbau ~$500/m² lifetime
Quality composite ~$460/m² lifetime
Composite wins on lifetime cost if you value your weekends

Common Questions

Over a 20-year period, quality composite (Modwood, Ekodeck, Trex) works out slightly cheaper than merbau timber once you factor in annual oiling costs and eventual board replacement. Australian hardwoods like spotted gum or blackbutt land between the two on lifetime cost.

Still Not Sure?

Every situation is different. Talk to us about your specific circumstances and we'll help you work out which option makes sense for you.

1300 885 919

Cookies on. Learn more