Builders rarely say no. They say "that is not standard", "we would have to look at that", "it is a variation", or "we do not usually do that". Each one is a real sentence with a real meaning and, most of the time, a way through. Here is what they mean and what to say back.
The pro listens for whether the answer is about physics, money or process. "The beam will not span that" is physics. "That is a variation" is money. "We do not do that at this stage" is process. Only one of them is a real no.
This is the most common one and the least final. Volume builders price a fixed range of products and details so the estimating is fast and the trades know what to expect. Anything outside the range is possible, it just needs to be priced and drawn. "Not standard" means not on the list, not impossible. The question to ask is what the upgrade path is, and whether it has been done before on this plan.
A variation is any change to the contract after it is signed. It is not a refusal, it is a notice that the change will be priced, written up and signed by both of you before it happens. The word only becomes a problem when it is used for something you thought was included. If you hear it before contract, ask for the change to be drawn into the plans and priced into the contract so it never becomes a variation at all.
Both are about sequence. Too late usually means the frame is up, the plaster is on or the order has been placed with a supplier. It is often genuinely too late, and the cost of undoing is real. Too early usually means the question belongs at a later meeting: colour selections, electrical walk, pre-plaster. It is a fair answer if you get a date for when it is the right time. It is a brush-off if nobody writes it down.
Sometimes true, often untested. Engineers do not forbid things, they size them. A bigger opening needs a bigger lintel or a steel beam. A wall removed needs the load carried another way. Those have a cost and sometimes a bulkhead, and the builder may not want the conversation. Ask whether the engineer has actually been asked. If they have, ask for the answer in writing. If they have not, ask what it would take to ask.
Listen to this one. It is often the builder's experience talking: the product fails, the detail leaks, the supplier is slow. Ask why. If the answer is specific, a product name and a failure they have seen, take it seriously. If the answer is vague, it usually means the trade does not like doing it or the margin is thin. You can still insist, and the builder may ask you to sign that you have been advised against it. That is fair.
Sales sends you to the estimator, the estimator to the drafter, the drafter to the supervisor, the supervisor to head office. Some of this is legitimate: the person in front of you genuinely cannot answer. Some of it is a loop designed to tire you out. The fix is to get names, and to put the question in an email to the person who can answer with a date you need it by.
Some things are actually no, and a good builder will tell you clearly. A ceiling height the trusses cannot give you without redesign. A room that would breach a setback. A window that cannot go on a boundary wall. A product the manufacturer will not warrant in a wet area. A change once the slab is poured. When you hear a no with a reason you can check, that is a builder being honest, and it is worth more than a yes that turns into a variation.
The pages on BuildPilot this guide leans on.
It means the item or detail is not in the builder's pre-priced range. It is usually possible as an upgrade or a client-supplied item; it just has to be priced and drawn.
Any change to the agreed contract, priced and signed by both parties before the work is done. The change attracts the builder's margin and often an admin fee. Changes made before contract, and drawn into the plans, are not variations.
Usually, yes. Ask what specifically they have seen go wrong. If you go ahead anyway, expect to sign an acknowledgement and check whether the warranty on that item is affected.
Once the item has been ordered from a supplier or the stage it belongs to has been built. Frame changes after plaster, slab changes after the pour, and window changes after the order are the common genuine ones.
Get the name of the person who can answer, put the question in an email to them with the salesperson copied in, and ask for a date. Written questions get written answers.
Sizes quoted are typical for Australian residential work and are given to help you read drawings and ask better questions. They are not a specification. Your engineer, designer, builder and the National Construction Code decide what applies to your house.
We use cookies to improve your experience. Cookies on. Learn more